Recently I became aware of some scholarly research done by German scholars into the inerrancy of the Quran. Some of their findings are discussed in an Atlantic Monthly article entitled "What Is the Koran?" written by Toby Lester, published in the January 1999 issue of that magazine. The gist of their research is that some very old fragments of the Quran found in a mosque in Yemen show small but significant aberrations from the standard Quranic texts. In some cases, the writing on the fragments found had been washed off and different writing substituted overtop. The article tries to cast doubt on the Muslim view of the Quran as being absolutely reliable, and tries to show instead that it is a literary text that has been subject to change just like any other.
I am not a Muslim, but I know that the Quran holds a position in Islam that is similar to that of Christ in Christianity. In view of this, sir, how would you respond to these attempts to dispute the absolute inerrancy of the Quran? In your view, do these scholars have false motives that render their findings untrustworthy? Or do you have another response to these attacks on the verity of the Quran?.
Praise be to Allaah.
1 – The proof that the copies of the Holy Qur’aan that we
have before us is not just one or two pieces of evidence, rather it is
proven by a vast amount of evidence that no fair-minded person can study
without becoming convinced that it is exactly as Allaah revealed it to
Muhammad (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him).
2 – There have been generations coming one after another,
reciting the Book of Allaah and studying it, memorizing it and writing it
down. They have not omitted a single letter, and no one can change even the
vowel point of a single letter. Writing is just one means of preserving it;
basically it is preserved in their hearts.
3 – The Qur’aan has not come down to us on its own, such that
the so-called alterations could be made. Rather the interpretation of its
verses, the meanings of its words, the reasons for its revelation, the
grammar of its words and the commentary on its rulings have all been
transmitted. When such care has been given to this Book, how could sinful
hands find a way to distort even one letter of it, or add a word, or take
away a verse?
4 – The Qur’aan speaks of matters of the unseen, in the
future, which Allaah revealed to His Messenger Muhammad (peace and
blessings of Allaah be upon him) to show him that they came from Allaah. If
a human being wants to write a book, he can describe an event or express a
point of view, but if any human being were to speak about matters of the
unseen, in this field he can only base that on speculation and lies. But the
Qur’aan told of the defeat of the Romans by the Persians, at the time when
there was no means of communication to inform the Arabs of this event. The
same verses also foretold that they (the Persians) would be defeated after a
certain number of years. If what the Qur’aan said was not accurate, then the
kaafirs would have had a great opportunity to criticize the Qur’aan.
5 – If you read any verse of the Qur’aan, then you go to
America or Asia or the jungles of Africa, or to the deserts of Arabia or any
place where there are Muslims, you will find that all of them have the exact
same verse, memorized by heart or in their books; not a single letter of it
will have been altered.
So what is the importance of this unknown manuscript in Yemen
which we have not seen, and in which some ignorant may have altered, in
recent times, one verse or one word?
Does this argument carry any weight when properly researched
and discussed? Especially when the people claim to be fair-minded and
objective in their research.
What would be their response if we went to one of their most
trusted books by a well-known author, a book of which there are many copies
in the world, all of them exactly the same, and we claimed that there was a
copy of this book in some country or other in which there was extra material
and alterations, and it was different from what is in their copies? Would
they pay any attention?
Their answer would be the same as ours.
6 – The manuscript copies which are in the Muslims’
possession cannot be proven to be authentic in this simplistic manner, for
we have experts who know the history of calligraphy and we have principles
and guidelines through which we may determine whether a manuscript is
genuine, such as the names and signatures of the people who heard it and
We do not think that these features are present in this
so-called copy of the Qur’aan in Yemen or in others.
7 – We are happy to conclude our answer with this true story
that happened in Baghdad during the ‘Abbasid era, when a Jew wanted to find
out how true are the books attributed by their followers to God, namely the
Torah among the Jews, the Gospel among the Christians and the Qur’aan among
He went to the Torah and added and took away a few minor
things that were not very obvious, then he gave it to a scribe from among
the Jews and asked him to make copies of it. It did not take long before
these copies were placed in the synagogues of the Jews and were in
circulation among their major scholars.
Then he went to the Gospel and added and took away a few
things as he had done with the Torah, and he gave it to their scribes and
asked them to make copies of it. It was not long before it was being read in
their churches and was in circulation among their scholars.
Then he went to the Qur’aan and added and took away a few
things as he had done with the Torah and the Gospel. Then he gave it to a
Muslim scribe to make copies of it.
When he went back to get his copy, the scribe threw it in his
face and told him that this was not the Qur’aan of the Muslims!
From this experiment the man came to know that the Qur’aan is
the true Book of Allaah and that all other books were the works of human
If the scribes of the Muslims could tell that this copy had
been tampered with, then how could it go into circulation among the Muslim
If the questioner wants to repeat this ancient experiment
nowadays, all she has to do is to do the same as that Jewish man did, who
later became Muslim; she can add and take away things from these three books
and see what happens as a result.
But we do not tell her to show her copy of the Qur’aan to a
scribe, rather we tell her to show it to Muslim children, and they will tell
her where the mistakes are in her copy!
Some Muslim states have printed Mus-hafs in which there were
mistakes, and young children found them before the grown-ups did!
And Allaah is the Guide to the Straight Path.